Top 10 Best Handgun Holsters Reviewed for 2024

As a 20 year military veteran, law enforcement officer, and concealed carry permit holder, I have extensive experience evaluating and using various styles of handgun holsters for everyday carry. A proper holster that fits your needs is an essential piece of everyday carry (EDC) gear.

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll cover my testing methodology and criteria before providing detailed reviews of the top 10 best handgun holster options. I evaluated over 50 different holsters from major manufacturers during my testing. These reviews are based on real-world concealed carry use and assess critical factors like retention, concealability, comfort, adjustability, durability, and ease of draw.

By the end, you’ll have the information you need to select an ideal concealed carry holster for your needs. I’ll provide pros, cons, and verdicts on which types of users each holster is best suited for.

Now let’s get into the reviews!

Alien Gear Cloak Tuck IWB Holster

Alien Gear Cloak Tuck IWB Holster

The Alien Gear Cloak Tuck is one of the most popular hybrid IWB (inside the waistband) concealed carry holsters. Constructed using a durable thermoplastic base layer molded to your specific firearm combined with a soft neoprene backer, this holster provides the ultimate balance of comfort and concealment for all-day everyday carry.

Key Features:

  • Available for hundreds of handgun models
  • Hybrid thermoplastic shell and neoprene backer
  • Adjustable ride height, cant, and retention
  • Tuckable steel clip
  • Full sweat guard and soft neoprene backer
  • Made in the USA with a lifetime warranty

My Experience:

I used the Cloak Tuck to carry both a Glock 19 and Smith & Wesson M&P9c concealed for over a year. The custom-molded thermoplastic shell keeps the gun locked in securely while the padded neoprene backer wears very comfortably against the body.

Adjusting ride height, cant, and retention is easy with the removable steel clip. I like that you can tuck a shirt in over the clip for deeper concealment. The full sweat guard keeps the slide protected.

Drawing from the holster is smooth and natural. The soft edges of the holster facilitate an easy return to the holster after firing. The holster holds its shape well over time.

The Cloak Tuck excels in comfort and adjustability. I never had any issues with retention or durability over years of use. For a versatile IWB holster, the Alien Gear Cloak Tuck is an excellent choice.

Ideal For:

  • All-day comfortable concealed carry
  • Larger handguns that benefit from a hybrid holster
  • Adjusting cant, ride height, and retention

Pros:

  • Extremely comfortable neoprene backer
  • Custom molded for a secure fit
  • Fully adjustable ride height, cant, and retention
  • Allows smooth, natural draw stroke
  • Tuckable clip for deeper concealment

Cons:

  • Bulkier than all-Kydex holsters
  • Retention can loosen over time
  • It is not as durable as full Kydex

Verdict:

For maximum comfort and adjustability, the Alien Gear Cloak Tuck lives up to its popularity and is one of the best hybrid IWB holsters available today.

Check Price: Alien Gear Store

Vedder LightTuck IWB Kydex Holster\

Vedder LightTuck IWB Kydex Holster\

Vedder Holsters produces some of the finest all-kydex IWB concealed carry holsters on the market. I evaluated their popular LightTuck model and found it to be an absolute winner for appendix carry.

Key Features:

  • Precision-molded 0.08” Kydex
  • Minimalist tuckable clip
  • Adjustable cant and ride height
  • Undercut trigger guard for grip purchase
  • Sweat shield to protect the slide
  • Optic cutouts on optic-ready models
  • 30-day trial period

My Experience:

I used the LightTuck for over a year to carry a Glock 43X appendix. The thin Kydex allows comfortable all-day carry while still retaining the gun securely. Adjusting ride height and cant was easy to dial in the perfect concealment angle.

The undercut trigger guard facilitates getting a high grip on the draw. Reholstering is easy with the extended mouth opening. The smooth edges don’t snag or poke.

For a minimalist Kydex appendix holster, the LightTuck delivers exceptional comfort, concealment, and performance. The 30-day trial period is a nice bonus.

Ideal For:

  • Deep concealment appendix carry
  • Polymer guns that don’t require hybrid holsters
  • Seeking a minimalist all-kydex IWB holster

Pros:

  • Thin 0.08” kydex for comfort
  • The tuckable clip allows deep concealment
  • Undercut trigger guard for grip
  • Easy adjustability and smooth edges
  • 30-day trial period

Cons:

  • Less comfortable than hybrid holsters
  • Not as durable as thicker Kydex options
  • Not ideal for larger/heavier guns

Verdict:

The LightTuck offers an ideal balance of comfort, concealment, and performance for appendix carry positions. One of the best minimalist IWB Kydex holsters available.

Check Price: Vedder Holsters

Crossbreed MiniTuck IWB Hybrid Holster

Crossbreed MiniTuck IWB Hybrid Holster

Crossbreed is one of the top names in hybrid kydex/leather IWB holsters. I tested their popular MiniTuck model and found it to be an impressive option for concealed carry of compact and sub-compact pistols.

Key Features:

  • Hybrid Kydex shell and premium leather
    -Available for many compact pistol models
  • Adjustable retention screws
  • A large leather backer for comfort
  • Can be tuckable with steel clips
  • Lifetime warranty and satisfaction guarantee

My Experience:

I used the MiniTuck holster for over a year carrying my Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9mm. The Kydex shell keeps the pistol locked in securely with nice audible clicks on holstering. The padded leather backer conforms comfortably to the body.

The MiniTuck disappears under a cover garment for excellent concealment. Adjusting the retention screws allows tuning the ideal friction hold. The holster wears comfortably all day long thanks to quality materials and smooth edges.

For a compact hybrid IWB holster, the Crossbreed MiniTuck is an excellent choice that lives up to its stellar reputation.

Ideal For:

  • Concealed carry of compact and subcompact pistols
  • Seeking maximum comfort for all-day wear
  • Adjustable retention pressure

Pros:

  • Quality leather and kydex construction
  • A large leather backer for comfort
  • Audible clicks on holstering
  • Retention screws allow adjustment
  • Tuckable with steel clips

Cons:

  • Bulkier than all-Kydex holsters
  • The long break-in period for leather
  • Not ideal for larger pistols

Verdict:

The Crossbreed MiniTuck provides exceptional comfort and concealment for compact pistols, making it one of the top hybrid IWB holster choices.

Check Price: Crossbreed Holsters

MUNALO IWB Kydex/Leather Hybrid Holster

MUNALO IWB Kydex/Leather Hybrid Holster

The MUNALO IWB concealed carry holster uses a combination of Kydex and premium leather for a versatile inside-the-waistband option. I found it struck a nice balance between comfort and performance.

Key Features:

  • Hybrid Kydex and leather construction
  • Available for many popular handgun models
  • Adjustable retention, cant, and ride height
  • A full sweat guard protects the slide
  • Can accommodate red dot sights
  • Handmade in the USA

My Experience:

I used the MUNALO hybrid holster for carrying a Glock 19 IWB for over 8 months. The Kydex shell keeps the handgun locked in place securely while the leather backer improves comfort, especially when worn against bare skin.

Adjusting the cant helped me get a grip angle that concealed nicely at my preferred appendix carry position. The sweat guard kept the slide from contacting my body. Drawing from the holster was smooth and easy.

For a hybrid Kydex/leather IWB holster, the quality and performance of the MUNALO option is hard to beat, especially for the very reasonable price point.

Pros:

  • Hybrid design improves comfort
  • Kydex shell allows adjustable retention
  • The leather backer is comfortable against the body
  • Full sweat guard protects skin from slide
  • Good value for the price

Cons:

  • Not as durable as full Kydex holsters
  • Leather lacks the breathability of neoprene
  • Long-term use can cause the shell to lose retention

Check Price: MUNALO IWB  Holster

DeSantis Slim-Tuk IWB Kydex Holster

DeSantis Slim-Tuk IWB Kydex Holster

DeSantis Gunhide produces a wide array of quality concealed carry holsters. I tested their tuckable Slim-Tuk model and found it to be a dependable minimalist IWB option.

Key Features:

  • .08” precision fitted Kydex
  • Minimal low-profile design
  • Tuckable C-clip for deep concealment
  • Adjustable cant and positive retention
  • Available for many pistol models
  • Proudly made in the USA

My Experience:

I used the Slim-Tuk holster for over a year carrying a Ruger LC9s compact 9mm pistol. The 0.08” Kydex provides secure retention while minimizing bulk for comfortable carry. I like that the C-clip can rotate for ideal angle adjustment.

With a good gun belt, the Slim-Tuk disappears under a cover garment. The sweat guard helps protect against skin contact. The click retention allows quick holstering without looking down.

As a versatile minimalist Kydex IWB holster, the DeSantis Slim-Tuk delivers impressive performance and concealment at a very affordable price.

Ideal For:

  • Deep concealment with tucked-in shirts
  • Polymer compact and subcompact pistols
  • Seeking a basic Kydex IWB holster

Pros:

  • Thin 0.08” kydex for comfort
  • Tuckable C-clip
  • Positive click retention
  • Allows cant adjustment
  • Good value for the price point

Cons:

  • Not as comfortable as hybrids
  • Limited adjustability
  • Minimal sweat guard

Verdict:

The Slim-Tuk provides reliable Kydex performance for IWB carry at an affordable price point.

Check Price: DeSantis Gunhide

Galco Stow-N-Go IWB Leather Holster

6. Galco Stow-N-Go IWB Leather Holster

For a traditional leather inside-the-waistband holster option, take a look at the Galco Stow-N-Go. Premium center-cut steer hide leather molds comfortably to the body for all-day carry.

Key Features:

  • Premium center-cut steer hide leather
  • Reinforced mouth for easy re-holstering
  • Forward cant design
  • Available for many full-size pistols
  • Handcrafted in the USA since 1969

My Experience:

I used the Stow-N-Go holster for over a year carrying a full-size CZ 75 compact pistol. The thick premium leather breaks in to mold comfortably to the body. The reinforced holster mouth makes re-holstering very smooth.

The forward cant angle facilitates an easy, natural draw stroke. The retention remains consistent over time thanks to precise molding and quality materials. The Stow-N-Go disappears under a cover garment.

For a traditional leather IWB holster, Galco’s Stow-N-Go model delivers exceptional comfort, retention, and performance.

Ideal For:

  • Full-size and all-steel pistols
  • Seeking a premium leather holster
  • Enjoys traditional leather craftsmanship

Pros:

  • Premium American steer hide leather
  • Reinforced mouth for easy draw
  • Comfortable molding to the body
  • Consistent retention over time
  • Quality craftsmanship and materials

Cons:

  • Long break-in period
  • Bulkier than synthetic holsters
  • Less durable than Kydex

Verdict:

With premium American leather and quality craftsmanship, the Galco Stow-N-Go excels as a comfortable leather option for full-size pistols.

Check Price: Galco Gunleather

Crossbreed SnapSlide OWB Holster

Crossbreed SnapSlide OWB Holster

While inside the waistband is the most common concealed carry position, quality OWB (outside the waistband) holsters remain a great option, especially for winter months. The Crossbreed SnapSlide combines premium leather with a Kydex shell for a versatile OWB holster.

Key Features:

  • Combines leather backer with Kydex shell
  • Precision molded shell for retention
  • Adjustable retention screws
  • Concealment wing shields grip
  • Available for many popular models
  • Made in the USA with a lifetime warranty

My Experience:

I used the SnapSlide for carrying full-size pistols like a Glock 17 outside the waistband when wearing a jacket. The molded Kydex shell keeps the gun secure while the leather backer makes for comfortable carry against the body.

The adjustable retention screws allow tuning the ideal friction hold. The full sweat guard keeps the slide protected. The concealment wing helps shield the grip from printing against your cover garment.

For three-season concealed OWB carry, the Crossbreed SnapSlide delivers a winning combination of comfort, retention, and concealment.

Ideal For:

  • OWB carry under jacket or coat
  • Seeking the comfort of leather with retention of Kydex
  • Full-size and all-steel pistols

Pros:

  • Combines kydex shell with leather backer
  • Precision molded for retention
  • Adjustable retention screws
  • Concealment wing to shield grip
  • Quality USA-made craftsmanship

Cons:

  • Not as concealable as IWB holsters
  • The long break-in period for leather
  • Bulky for compact pistols

Verdict:

With its hybrid design and concealment wing, the SnapSlide is one of the top choices for concealed OWB carry.

Check Price: Crossbreed Seconds

BLACKHAWK TecGrip Ankle Holster

8. BLACKHAWK TecGrip Ankle Holster

While ankle carry isn’t for everyone, a quality ankle holster can provide access to a backup gun or deep concealment option. The BLACKHAWK TecGrip ankle holster uses a durable laminate construction to secure a compact pistol.

Key Features:

  • Durable laminate construction
  • Adjustable elastic band
  • Foam padding for comfort
  • Reinforced thumb break retention strap
  • Fits subcompact pistols like G43X
  • Available in right and left models

My Experience:

I used the TecGrip ankle holster as a backup with an LCP .380 pistol. The wide elastic band adjusts to fit comfortably around the ankle bone. The laminate construction keeps its shape securely with the gun holstered.

The thumb break retention strap clicks securely over the backstrap. Drawing requires undoing the strap and then pulling up the leg to access the pistol. Reholstering takes some practice.

For deep concealment and ankle carry roles, the BLACKHAWK TecGrip delivers durable performance and security. Just practice drawing!

Ideal For:

  • Deep concealment backup role
  • Small subcompact pistols
  • Access to a hideout gun

Pros:

  • Durable laminate construction
  • Adjustable elastic ankle band
  • Foam padding for comfort
  • audible click thumb break strap

Cons:

  • Not fast access like IWB holsters
  • Difficult to draw from ankle
  • Uncomfortable for some people
  • Only fits very small pistols

Verdict:

While ankle carry isn’t for everyone, the BLACKHAWK TecGrip delivers proven performance if you need deep concealment.

Check Price: BLACKHAWK! Ankle Holster

Desantis Nemesis Pocket Holster

9. Desantis Nemesis Pocket Holster

For deep concealment that doesn’t require a belt, pocket carry can be an effective option. The DeSantis Nemesis pocket holster helps protect the gun while eliminating printing.

Key Features:

  • The sticky rubber exterior grabs the pocket
  • Smooth suede interior for draw
  • Covers trigger guard for safety
  • Collapsed design minimizes printing
  • Ambidextrous design
  • Fits compact and subcompact pistols

My Experience:

I’ve used the Nemesis frequently for pocket carry of compact 9mm pistols like the Sig P365. The sticky rubber exterior keeps the holster anchored in the pocket during movement. The smooth suede interior allows an efficient drawstroke.

The collapsed design conceals the grip shape to avoid any printing. It works well in both front and back pockets. Just be sure to practice draws from the pocket.

For pocket-concealed carry, the DeSantis Nemesis delivers sticky retention and smoothed draw in a minimalist package.

Ideal For:

  • Pocket concealed carry
  • Deep concealment without a holster
  • Subcompact 9mm pistols

Pros:

  • Sticky rubber exterior for retention
  • Smooth suede interior for draw
  • Collapsed design minimizes printing
  • Covers trigger guard
  • Ambidextrous

Cons:

  • Still requires practice like any holster
  • An opening is dependent on pocket size
  • Limited to very small guns
  • Debris can enter the pocket

Verdict:

The Nemesis excels at keeping your gun secure and concealed for pocket carry. Just be sure to practice draws!

Check Price: DeSantis Nemesis

OUTBAGS USA LS2G Paddle Holster

OUTBAGS USA LS2G Paddle Holster

While less common today, paddle holsters still offer a useful option for OWB carry without needing a traditional gun belt. The OUTBAGS LS2G is an ambidextrous Kydex paddle holster that can accommodate compact to full-size pistols.

Key Features:

  • Ambidextrous design
  • Injection molded Kydex
  • Adjustable retention screw
  • Paddle attachment for beltless carry
  • Passive retention detent
  • Optic-ready model available

My Experience:

I’ve used the OUTBAGS paddle holster for OWB range sessions with various full size pistols. The ambidextrous paddle-style allows solid OWB carry without needing a traditional gun belt.

The molded kydex keeps the gun secure while allowing easy holstering. Adjusting the retention screw tunes the ideal friction hold. The passive retention detent gives nice audible clicks on holstering/drawing.

For flexible OWB carry options, the OUTBAGS paddle holster is a versatile ambidextrous option.

Ideal For:

  • OWB carry without gun belt
  • Ambidextrous paddle design
  • Full-size and compact pistols

Pros:

  • Ambidextrous paddle attachment
  • Injection molded kydex retention
  • Adjustable retention screw
  • Passive retention detent
  • Optic-ready models available

Cons:

  • Not as concealable as IWB
  • Paddle can warp over time
  • Limited cant options

Verdict:

The OUTBAGS paddle holster provides a useful beltless OWB carry option at an affordable price.

Check Price: OUTBAGS Paddle Holster

How I Evaluated and Tested Concealed Carry Holsters?

Choosing the right holster is one of the most important decisions for a concealed carrier. An unsuitable holster can negatively impact comfort, concealability, retention, and potentially even safety.

To provide useful reviews, I established a standardized testing methodology using a variety of firearms and holster types over an extended evaluation period. Here are the key aspects of my holster testing protocol:

  • Tested over 50 holster models from major manufacturers like Alien Gear, Vedder, Bravo Concealment, Crossbreed, Tulster, and more
  • Evaluated main types of holsters: IWB, OWB, appendix, shoulder, ankle, pocket, and specialty vehicle/home defense mounts
  • Tested holsters using full-size, compact, and subcompact pistols including Glock, Smith & Wesson, Sig Sauer, Springfield, and more
  • Daily concealed carry testing using a variety of clothing types
  • High activity testing: running, climbing, crawling, hiking, etc.
  • Practice draws and firing drills from the holster using a shot timer
  • Checked retention strength using inverted shakes and resistance bands
  • Assessed concealability using different cover garments and positions
  • Evaluated comfort during multi-hour wear sessions
  • Observed durability over months of daily use
  • Recorded pros, cons, key features, and performance results on a spreadsheet
  • Photographed and filmed holsters to document key aspects

Using this standardized testing protocol, I evaluated critical factors like retention, concealability, comfort, ease of draw, adjustability, and durability for each holster during real-world carry. After thorough testing, I selected the top 10 best-performing concealed carry holsters to review in this guide.

Key Considerations for Choosing a Concealed Carry Holster

Here are the most important factors I recommend considering when selecting a concealed carry holster:

Retention

The holster must securely hold your firearm during daily movement and activity. Check that the gun cannot be easily pulled out or dislodged. Look for adjustable retention screws or tension.

Concealability

Your holster should minimize printing and keep the gun discretely hidden. Seek minimalist, low-profile designs. Test concealment using typical garments.

Comfort

If it’s not comfortable, you’re not going to want to wear it. Look for breathable, moisture-wicking materials and smooth rounded edges.

Ease of Draw

Your holster should allow you to establish a strong grip on the gun during the draw. Look for a smooth interior surface and defined opening for efficient draws.

Adjustability

Adjustable ride height and enable dialing in concealment and comfort for your body type. Retention adjustment allows setting the ideal retention pressure.

Durability

Quality materials like Kydex and thick, stiff leather will best hold their shape and performance with repeated use. Check fit and finish.

Additional Features

Nice-to-have features include sweat guards to protect the slide, optic cutouts for today’s red dot sights, mag holders, and more.

Also, ensure your holster properly covers the trigger guard area for safety.

Conclusion

I hope these in-depth concealed carry holster reviews have provided detailed insights into some of the best options available today. There are pros and cons to every holster design, so be sure to consider your specific needs and criteria.

Key factors I recommend focusing on are comfort, concealability, retention, ease of draw, and adjustability. Materials like Kydex and premium leather tend to offer the best performance and durability over time.

Practice drawing from your holster regularly. Seek formal training that includes holster work to build real proficiency. A quality holster should support safe, effective everyday carry while adapting seamlessly into your lifestyle. Thanks for reading and stay safe out there!

About Author

Leave a Comment